The Signal Hiding Inside November’s Revenue Spike

Your Weekly DTC Industry Roundup

Another strange, slightly sideways week in ecommerce, the kind founders feel in their bones before they ever see it in the dashboards. Platforms are tightening screws, customers are hesitating, and the brands with real operational discipline are starting to pull away from the ones hoping creative alone can save Q4.

Shopify pushed a batch of AI and catalog upgrades that reward clean data and punish chaos. TikTok Shop made it even clearer that sloppy ops aren’t a rounding error — they’re a risk profile. And November revenue? It’s rising, but only because your existing customers are doing all the work while new shoppers sit on their hands waiting for the real deals.

Meanwhile, October’s numbers look solid enough to call “momentum,” yet Meta performance data is flashing a quiet warning to anyone thinking about throttling spend before Black Friday.

Here's what happened:

• Shopify rolled out new AI tools and catalog upgrades that quietly favor operators with clean data and smart product architecture
• TikTok Shop’s Policy Shift Turns Ops Weakness Into Risk
• November Revenue Is Climbing — But Only Because Your Existing Customers Are Carrying You
• October Data Shows ‘Continued Momentum’ Going Into Holiday Season
• The Truth About Meta Performance Before Black Friday (Stop Pulling Spend!)

Let's get into it.

Sponsor

Maximize every dollar during BFCM with FERMÀT’s Offer & Price Testing

FERMÀT is the leading AI funnel builder that helps ecommerce brands create high-converting landing pages without designers or developers.

Their features include: AI-powered landing pages and PDPs generated in minutes, A/B testing and experimentation tools, seamless integration with your ad platforms and Shopify checkout, customizable funnel templates, real-time performance optimization, and more!

We're partnering with FERMÀT to offer readers an exclusive 7-day trial.

Try fermat

Platform Updates

Shopify’s Quiet AI Upgrades Reward Merchants With Real Merchandising Discipline

Shopify has been busy. On the surface, the headline is an AI helper “that’s helping independent brands compete with retail giants this holiday season” and a growing set of generative tools around analytics and image editing.

Under the hood, merchants now get natural-language analytics through Sidekick, AI background generation for product photos, support for up to 2,048 variants per product, smarter smart collections (including “is not equal to” for tags), and better international pricing behavior via Markets in things like Draft Order checkouts.

This isn’t just “neat AI stuff.” It’s a structural shift: operators who have clear product hierarchies, clean tags, sensible collections, and reliable attribution fields will get far more out of these tools. You can ask questions of your store in plain language, but the quality of the answer is chained to your data hygiene. The brands that treat Shopify as a real system of record rather than a dumping ground for SKUs will move faster on merchandising pivots, promo logic, and international testing next year.

See more details here

Platform Survival

TikTok Shop’s Policy Shift Turns Ops Weakness Into Risk

This week, TikTok Shop rolled out a major policy pulse. Key updates include:

A new metric, the Non-Buyer Fault Return & Refund Rate (NBFR), now formally affects shop health (SPS) by penalizing missing, wrong, or damaged items.

Return/refund shipping cost sharing: for “item no longer needed / wrong size,” the cost will now be split BETWEEN the seller and TikTok — but high-performing sellers (strong SPS) can get subsidies up to 80%.

Campaign eligibility criteria ahead of BFCM: shops need SPS ≥3.5 (or null with no violations), Account Health Rating >150, On-Time Delivery Rate ≥80%, Seller Fault Cancellation Rate ≤5%, free shipping threshold ≤$30.

Here’s why it matters for you.

If your ops haven’t been tight—inventory accuracy, fulfillment speed, packaging quality—you might be underpricing your risk in the TikTok channel. On-screen ROAS can look high, but NBFR isn’t visible in most dashboards until your visibility dips, your SPS drops, or your live-streams get restricted. That’s indirect growth tax.

See full details

ecommerce Performance

November Revenue Is Climbing — But Only Because Your Existing Customers Are Carrying You

Total Revenue is having a strong start to the month. In the first nine days of November, revenue is up +15.70% compared to the last nineteen days of October. That’s the headline number.

Zoom out to the full 28-day window and the picture changes: revenue is only +1.62% YoY, and since November 1st, it’s actually running below last year. This isn’t a market-wide slump — it’s a customer-mix problem.

Returning customers are doing the heavy lifting. Their revenue is +9.87% YoY, which makes sense. They already trust the brands they buy from, and they weren’t planning to wait around for the perfect discount window.

New customers are the opposite story. New customer revenue is down -6.19% YoY, which tracks with what we’re seeing in the DTC Confidence Index:

Future Purchase Sentiment just hit a record high, more than 8% above the same week last year. That’s not enthusiasm — it’s customers saying, “I’m ready to buy, just not until the real deals show up.”

So yes, brands can try to “start Black Friday early,” but consumers know the game. They wait until the full discount landscape is visible, and only then do they decide where to buy.

Discounts tell the same story. They’re rising, but still behind last year — 10.46% today vs. 11.13% at this point in 2024. Early signals say the climb is coming, but it hasn’t hit its peak yet.

We’ll keep tracking whether those discounts accelerate — and whether new customers finally release the pent-up demand they’re holding until Black Friday week.

Get the DTC index

Market Performance

Holiday Demand Is Fine. Your Margin Discipline Might Not Be.

October came in hot: US consumers spent $88.7B online, up 8.2% year over year. Mobile crossed the halfway mark at 51.4% of spend, and BNPL hit $7.1B for the month, about 8% of total ecommerce sales and up 7.6% YoY. Offline isn’t dead either—core retail sales (excluding restaurants, autos, gas) rose 0.6% month over month and 4.89% year over year in October, with total sales up just over 5% for the first ten months of 2025.

Translation for a founder staring at a noisy dashboard: demand is there. It’s just more fragmented and more promotion-sensitive than you’d like. AI-assisted shopping flows are pulling traffic into retailer experiences where product discovery and checkout feel faster, and BNPL is quietly propping up AOV for cost-conscious customers. That mix is great for top-line, but it can mask discount creep and higher payment costs if you don’t split out performance by payment method and promo type.

If your forecast assumes “flat conversion, flat discounting, modest growth,” you’re probably underestimating how much of your volume will come via mobile, BNPL, and early promo windows in Q4. This is the year to track performance by demand trigger—full price vs promo vs BNPL vs loyalty—and protect your best-margin segments instead of chasing every dollar that shows up.

Read more details

Podcast

The Truth About Meta Performance Before Black Friday (Stop Pulling Spend!)

Everyone panics in early November … but your Meta ROAS isn’t actually broken, you’re just looking at the wrong numbers.

In today’s episode of The DTC Hotline, we break down the real truth about Meta performance leading into Black Friday: why efficiency always looks terrible right now, how delayed attribution works, and why this is the single worst moment to pull back on spend.

Tony, Luke, and Richard walk through:

The 7-day vs 28-day attribution gap most brands ignore

Why 80% of your value shows up late (and 20% shows up way later)

How to know if you should hold or adjust your spend

The BFCM offer structures that actually perform

Why Black Friday ALWAYS works — and why the winners keep spending

If you’re feeling the November fear… Hold the line. Trust the data. Plant the seeds now.

Watch now

Final Thoughts

What This Means for Founders

Founders keep asking some version of the same question right now: “Is this holiday season going to break in our favor, or are we about to get squeezed again?” And honestly, the answer depends a lot less on demand and a lot more on how clean your operation is.

Shopify is rewarding brands with tidy catalogs and sensible merchandising. TikTok Shop is hammering anyone who treats fulfillment like an afterthought. Meta is still delivering if you let it breathe instead of panic-pulling spend. And customers? They’re showing up — just later, pickier, and with a very clear sense of when they expect value to appear.

What ties all of this together is something most mid-market founders hate admitting: Q4 isn’t won by creativity or ambition. It’s won by structure. Catalog discipline, predictable ops, steady media buying, and a clear view of which customers are actually driving your revenue right now.

The brands that will feel calm in December are the ones treating this season like a systems test, not a guessing game. Everyone else is just hoping the platforms play nice.

Your job this month is simple: remove friction, stay visible, and don’t confuse customer patience with customer weakness. They’re ready to buy — just not until they say so.