Why Rutsu Barefoot Switched Email Platforms Mid-Growth (And What It Actually Took)

Most brands avoid platform migrations like the plague. The conventional wisdom is that it's risky, disruptive, and not worth the headache while you're in growth mode. Rutsu Barefoot did it anyway, mid-growth, while scaling toward eight figures, and the experience turned out to be far simpler than expected.

In this episode of the eCommerce Playbook podcast, CTC's SVP of Strategy Luke Austin sat down with Gil Dyen, who leads marketing at Rutsu Barefoot, to go under the hood of their migration from Klaviyo to Omnisend. What actually triggered the decision, what the migration process looked like step by step, and what other brands should know before making the same move.

Why Email Became a Strategic Priority

Rutsu Barefoot launched 18 months before this episode, sold nearly 45,000 units, and was targeting 80,000 units in the following year. Around 80% of their ad budget went to Meta, with Google making up most of the rest. But the strategic direction of the business pointed toward retention. In year one, returning customers were around 12% of revenue. The goal was to reach 45% by year three.

That ambition made the email and SMS platform decision one of the most important infrastructure calls the brand could make at this stage. Getting it wrong now would mean undoing it later at a much more expensive and complicated time.

What Actually Drove the Platform Switch

The decision came down to two things: cost and simplicity. As a bootstrapped brand focused on profit from day one, Gil's operating principle was to minimize spending on SaaS so every available dollar could go into Meta spend and creative. Every dollar saved on tooling was a dollar that could compound through paid media.

But it wasn't just about cutting costs. The platform also needed to be simple enough that it didn't consume disproportionate time to manage. Gil described his day starting at 5am coordinating with a VA in the Philippines, then working with the founder on product development, then handling online marketing. Time is the real constraint for a lean team scaling fast, and any platform migration had to be straightforward enough to execute without disrupting everything else.

"We need to put every dollar that we can into marketing and into growth, not into SaaS. We're a small brand, we bootstrap, and we want to grow fast." — Gil Dyen, Rutsu Barefoot

Omnisend won on both dimensions: meaningfully lower cost than Klaviyo, and a managed migration process that meant Gil's team didn't have to figure it out alone.

About Omnisend: Omnisend is an email and SMS marketing platform built for ecommerce brands. It connects natively with Shopify, handles full account migrations end-to-end, and integrates with CTC's Statlas system for forecast-level revenue tracking across email and SMS channels. CTC uses Omnisend across the portfolio as a preferred platform for growing 7 and 8-figure brands.

What the Migration Actually Looked Like

The full migration took less than 30 days. Here is how the process broke down:

Data migration (days 1-5): Omnisend runs a dedicated migration app that handles everything in the background. Contacts, lists, segments, email templates, flows, and automations all transfer over without manual rebuild. For Rutsu Barefoot, this took a few days to complete and required essentially no time from Gil during that window.

QA and flow review (4-5 hours): Once the migration completed, Gil allocated roughly half a day to go through every flow, every email, every dynamic field, and every link. Most things came over clean. A small number of dynamic content elements needed minor adjustments. Nothing required a rebuild from scratch.

Gil noted that this QA step was actually valuable beyond the migration itself. Flows have a tendency to get set and forgotten. Going back through all of them was an opportunity to refresh copy, add branches to sequences, and improve automations that had been running untouched for months.

"It was a really good opportunity to go over the flows again and refresh things and make things better. The migration actually gave us a chance to benefit from that." — Gil Dyen

Warm-up phase (9 days for a 60,000-contact list): Rather than send immediately to the full list, Omnisend runs a structured warm-up by breaking the list into progressively larger segments, starting with the most engaged subscribers and doubling daily. For Rutsu Barefoot's 60,000-contact list, this took nine days.

Gil's advice: find a window where you can afford to send emails that aren't critical. During warm-up, not everyone on the list receives every send. If you're running a major sale or a key campaign during that window, some contacts will miss it. Plan the migration timing around low-stakes email periods, not around Q4 or your biggest promotional moments.

What Other Brands Should Know Before Migrating

A few practical considerations that came out of the conversation:

• Timing is everything. Do not start a migration in Q4. Plan for a 30-day window during a period when your email cadence can absorb some disruption without business consequences.
• The migration handles more than you expect. Lists, segments, templates, flows, and automations all come over. The QA work is real but it's hours, not weeks.
• Your migration is your audit. Use the forced review of every flow as an opportunity to improve what you have, not just replicate it.
• Managed migration changes the calculus. The reason most brands avoid migrations is the fear of complexity. When the platform manages the process end-to-end, that fear largely disappears.

The Bigger Picture: Platform Costs and Growth Allocation

What makes this story interesting beyond the migration itself is the strategic logic behind it. Rutsu Barefoot isn't cutting costs to save money. They're cutting costs in low-leverage areas so they can deploy more capital in high-leverage ones. Every dollar not spent on an enterprise email platform is a dollar that can go into Meta spend, into creative, into the acquisition engine that drives the growth they're trying to compound.

That kind of P&L discipline, being profitable from day one while still growing fast, is increasingly the playbook for bootstrapped brands trying to scale to eight figures without outside capital. Getting the platform stack right is part of that equation.

CTC integrates with Omnisend and all major email and SMS platforms through Statlas, tracking email and SMS revenue against forecast daily to make sure the channel is hitting its targets. If you're thinking through your email platform stack and how it connects to your broader growth forecast, it's worth a conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Ready to Dial In Your Email and SMS Strategy?

CTC's retention team builds and manages email and SMS programs for 7, 8, and 9-figure ecommerce brands, integrated with the Prophit Engine to forecast and hit channel-level revenue targets every month.

Talk to Us