"Our agency gives us execution, not strategy." We hear some version of this from almost every brand that reaches out to us. And it's completely valid. But it doesn't go far enough.
What brands actually want isn't better strategy or faster execution. It's someone who will commit to an outcome and own the path to get there.
Think about what you're paying for when you hire a growth partner. There are three tiers, and most relationships never get past the first two.
Execution is the baseline. Campaigns go live on time. QA is tight. The work gets done. But you're still telling them what to do.
Strategy is the ascension. The partner brings a methodology. Data-backed decisions. A point of view on where to allocate, what to test, how to grow.
Outcome is the thing everyone actually wants but almost nobody commits to. The partner commits to a number and owns the result. If the forecast says $500K in contribution margin this month, they do whatever is necessary to get there.
If the outcome isn't there, the strategy is irrelevant. If the strategy isn't there, the execution is just busy work.
Right now, most brands either tell the mechanic how to fix the car (execution) or the mechanic tells you how and then leaves (strategy). Either way, it's your problem if the car doesn't run.
What you actually want is a mechanic who takes the car, diagnoses the problem, fixes it, and is accountable if it doesn't work. You're pre-authorized for the outcome.
That's how the Prophit Engine operates. Here's the forecast. Here's the plan. If we fall behind, we deploy more campaigns, shift more budget, build more creative. That's on us. Flat retainer tied to the outcome, not a percentage of activity.
How predictable is the outcome? If the error bars on your forecast are plus or minus 30%, that's a guess. The widest acceptable margin should be plus or minus 10%. Across our portfolio, we operate at 3% to target across billions in managed revenue.
Is the outcome growing? Predictable decline isn't worth celebrating. Contribution margin needs to be growing over time.
3% forecast accuracy across billions in managed revenue. That isn't a prediction. It's a commitment to making the number right every single day.
If your current partner can't tell you the exact contribution margin target for this month and what they're doing today to hit it, the relationship is execution at best.
Common Thread Collective is the leading source of strategy and insight serving DTC ecommerce businesses. From agency services to educational resources for eccomerce leaders and marketers, CTC is committed to helping you do your job better.
For more content like this, sign up for our newsletter, listen to our podcast, or follow us on YouTube or Twitter.